Irishman Movie Review: Safe For Kids?

The release of Martin Scorsese’s “The Irishman” in 2019 sparked a multitude of discussions, not just about its epic storytelling, rich characters, and historical significance, but also about its suitability for various audiences, including children. As a film that delves into the world of organized crime, violence, and mature themes, it’s natural for parents and guardians to question whether “The Irishman” is safe for kids. To address this, let’s dive into the core elements of the movie and evaluate its content.

Historically Grounded Narrative

“The Irishman” is based on the real-life story of Frank Sheeran, a hitman who claimed to have been involved in the disappearance of Jimmy Hoffa, the infamous leader of the International Brotherhood of Teamsters. The film’s narrative spans decades, offering a glimpse into the life of Sheeran (played by Robert De Niro) and his involvement with the Bufalino crime family, led by Russell Bufalino (Joe Pesci). The historical context and the exploration of loyalty, power, and the consequences of one’s actions are central themes.

Violence and Mature Content

One of the primary concerns for parents considering whether “The Irishman” is appropriate for children is the film’s depiction of violence. While the violence is not excessively graphic compared to some modern standards, it is undeniable and sometimes shocking. Scenes of shootings, physical altercations, and implications of more brutal acts are scattered throughout the film, reflecting the harsh realities of the world it portrays. Additionally, the movie contains strong language and references to mature themes, including adultery and the personal and familial costs of a life in organized crime.

Thematic Complexity

Beyond the surface-level violence and mature content, “The Irishman” explores complex themes that may not resonate with younger audiences and could be challenging for them to fully understand. The movie delves into the psychological effects of a life of violence, the weight of secrets, and the erosion of loyalty and friendship over time. These themes are presented in a nuanced and layered manner, making the film more suited to adult viewers who can appreciate the depth and complexity of the narrative.

Guidance for Parents

For parents wondering if “The Irishman” is suitable for their children, the answer largely depends on the child’s age and maturity level. The film is rated R for a reason, primarily due to the pervasive language, violence, and some suggestive content. Children and younger teenagers may not only find certain scenes disturbing but may also struggle to grasp the film’s thematic depth and historical context.

• Young Children (Under 13): Definitely not suitable due to violence, language, and mature themes.
• Teenagers (13-17): While mature teenagers might be able to understand some of the film’s themes, parental discretion is advised. The content could be too intense for many in this age group.
• Young Adults (18 and Over): More appropriate, as young adults can better understand the historical and thematic contexts, as well as make more informed decisions about the content they consume.

Conclusion

“The Irishman” is a masterpiece of contemporary cinema, offering insights into a pivotal period in American history and the intricate, often brutal world of organized crime. However, its suitability for children is limited due to its mature themes, violence, and strong language. Parents should exercise caution and consider their child’s sensitivity and maturity level before deciding to watch “The Irishman” together. For most families, this film will be more appropriately enjoyed by adult viewers who can appreciate its complexity and historical significance without the concerns associated with exposing younger audiences to its content.